The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Right Antler Chew for Your Dog

Table of Contents

At TM Antlers, we’re proud to offer naturally shed deer and elk antlers from the beautiful Pacific Northwest. Every season our antler tracking pup, Trigger Moose, helps walk us through the open forests of the PNW looking for the first signs of elk and deer. With his help, every antler is collected sustainably and hand-crafted into a healthy, long-lasting chew your dog will love.

But how do you know which antler is right for your dog? Choosing the correct size and chew strength is important for your dog’s safety, their enjoyment, and to make your antler last as long as possible.

This guide will make it easy.

Why Size Matters

Dogs come in all shapes and sizes, and so do antlers. A chew that’s too small can be a choking hazard for a big dog, while a chew that’s too large can be tough for a small pup to enjoy. That’s why choosing the right size means:

  • Better chewing comfort

  • Safer chewing experience

  • Longer-lasting antlers

Why Chewing Strength Matters

Some dogs are light nibblers, while others are full-on power chewers. In our experience, it’s often best to start your dog off with a good set of split antlers to see their initial reaction and desire for the chew. To help you choose, we’ve grouped antlers into Light, Moderate, and Heavy Chewer categories:

  • Light Chewers: Puppies, older dogs, or dogs that chew gently. Split antlers are great here because they expose the soft marrow.

  • Moderate Chewers: Most adult dogs fall here. A mix of split and whole antlers works well.

  • Heavy Chewers: These are the dogs that go to work on their chews! Whole antlers are best for durability.

Antler Chew Size & Chewer Guide

Antler Type Best Dog Size Chewing Strength Description Link
X-Small Whole Elk Antler Small (5–20 lbs) Light Perfect for puppies and toy breeds View Product
Small Deer Antler Small (5–20 lbs) Light Easy to handle for little dogs View Product
Small Whole Elk Antler Small–Medium Light / Moderate Good for small dogs who chew more actively View Product
Medium Deer Antler Medium (20–40 lbs) Moderate Great everyday chew View Product
Medium Split Elk Antler Medium (20–40 lbs) Light Easier to chew with marrow exposed View Product
Medium Whole Elk Antler Medium–Large Moderate / Heavy Ideal for medium dogs that love to chew View Product
Large Deer Antler Large (40–70 lbs) Moderate A hearty chew for big dogs View Product
Large Split Elk Antler Large (40–70 lbs) Light / Moderate Great for seniors or big pups easing into antlers View Product
Large Whole Elk Antler Large (40–70 lbs) Moderate / Heavy Durable option for strong chewers View Product
XL Deer Antler XL (70+ lbs) Moderate Good for big dogs who chew steadily View Product
XL Split Elk Antler XL (70+ lbs) Light / Moderate A big but more gentle chew View Product
XL Whole Elk Antler XL (70+ lbs) Heavy Perfect for extra-large power chewers View Product
XXL Split Elk Antler XL (70+ lbs) Light / Moderate Easy-chew option for gentle giants View Product
XXL Whole Elk Antler XL (70+ lbs) Heavy The toughest chew in our lineup View Product

 

Sustainably Sourced from the Pacific Northwest

All of our antlers come from naturally shed elk and deer. No animals are harmed. After we collect them, they’re cleaned, cut, and sanded to give your dog a safe, natural, and healthy chewing experience.

Antlers are packed with minerals, help keep teeth clean, and can keep your pup busy for hours.

For us, these antlers aren’t just products we offer online and in stores, they’re part of the great land we love and a way to give dogs something natural, healthy, and enduring. Thanks for trusting us to be part of your dog’s story.

Ready to Pick the Perfect Antler?

Browse our shop and use the Size and Chewer Type filters to find the perfect match. Whether you’ve got a tiny pup or a gentle giant, we’ve got an antler they’ll love.

👉 Shop Antler Chews

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Give Your Dog a Treat That Gives Back

  At TM Antlers, we’re passionate about providing dogs with healthy, natural chews sourced right from the wild landscapes of

Why Buy From TM Antlers

When you choose TM Antlers, you are not just buying a dog chew toy. You are giving your best friend

$1 From Every Sale Goes to Support Lizzy in Her Time of Need - Join Us in Support